Saving IHRA Alky FC

Discussion in 'Pit Buzz' started by Will Hanna, Dec 6, 2006.

  1. Will Hanna

    Will Hanna We put the 'inside' in Top Alcohol
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    May 6, 2003
    Messages:
    6,706
    Likes Received:
    132
    IHRA Alky FC as we know it is on the ropes right now. Either a sponsor steps up or AFC will step out. We know that to be official.

    However, when IHRA management leaves the sponsor hunting to the racer, that should send a message.

    Word on the street is the tab for the class is to the tune of $300K and the hottest lead is Ethanol along with a few associates picking up the tab. Rumor also has it if Ethanol comes in, Ethanol will be mandatory. We'll save that for a seperate conversation.

    Now the last few times I proposed this, I just about got shot at. I still think the IHRA AFC class needs to take a hard look at allowing screw blowers in. I think you can hang enough weight and wicker bill on a screw car to make it comparable to a roots car.

    My initial suggestion would be a screw blower car could run in NHRA trim at a minimum weight of 2375 (+100 lbs) and 3" wicker bill minimum.

    Here's the pro's I see of this:

    1. It will bring new blood to the IHRA class. Will the Manzo's and Payne's of the world cross over? Maybe, maybe not. I'm sure quite a few Div. 1 and 3 cars would run both. It would really help the western IHRA races such as San Antonio, Tulsa, and Edmonton. That will help the class and help it's future immensely.

    2. Like I said last year, it looks like the writing is on the wall anyway. To stay competitive, it looks like you'll be buying a PSI one way or the other or whatever new blower tricks and mods come out. Why not have the option of a screw blower which gives you more racing options?

    3. Expense. That will be a debate that goes on for years. I haven't tuned a competitive roots car, but I can't see where a competitive roots car would be hands down cheaper than a competitive screw car. Any comparison you could ever make involves factors that probably have more effect than the blower type on the manifold.

    4. Options, not change. Such a move would be more about options to existing IHRA racers and opening doors for current NHRA racers. It wouldn't be intended to make the screw blower the blower of choice. The rules would need to reflect that.

    I enjoy watching and monitoring the IHRA side. It is it's own brand due to the roots. However, without change, I think screw blowers or quitting will be inevitable quite possibly as early as next year.

    IHRA racers, let us hear from you. If I'm wrong, what's right? I'm open minded. I just want to help the IHRA guys out.
     
    #1
  2. Thurston

    Thurston New

    Joined:
    Oct 25, 2004
    Messages:
    183
    Likes Received:
    0
    Screw Blowers

    Hi Will, you just know I going to have to toss my 2 cents in on this subject. What follows is something I posted on another board. Please keep in mind, no slam intended on NHRA or screw blowers.

    Having raced IHRA since 1990 and now a crew chief on an AFC in IHRA, I have to say screws are a very bad idea. Many racers and many fans go to IHRA races because they offer something different then NHRA. Pro Mods are a prime example of why fan consider IHRA a great alterative, so much so that NHRA has adapted the class and now offers a Top Sportsman and Top Dragster class to tap into that customer base, why, because they have fan appeal. If the AFC in IHRA looks, sounds and runs just like their NHRA cousins, and does not differentiate themselves the whole deal becomes homogenized, then spectators and racers can just go to NHRA races to see the same things. The same goes for Alcohol dragsters; making them part of IHRA will only make a great organization look more and more like NHRA. IHRA has always been a leader in many areas when it came to putting on great shows for fans. IHRA needs to continue to lead not follow.

    Ok get out your guns, I've got my vest on, and medical team is standing by.

    Jim Thurston
    Crew Chief
    TNT Motor Sports
    Mich Fab Dodge Stratus
     
    #2
  3. Will Hanna

    Will Hanna We put the 'inside' in Top Alcohol
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    May 6, 2003
    Messages:
    6,706
    Likes Received:
    132
    ihra vs nhra

    I don't buy into the differentiation deal. I don't think the current IHRA management is either.

    Remember how big a deal it was any time any of the NHRA fuel stars crossed over and ran an IHRA event? Cory Mac to run here, Hillary Will to run there, JR Todd to run over here...etc.

    Jim, I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but if something doesn't happen, yall are going to be out of a class. At this point how many new IHRA A/FC teams do you think are going together? It would be a foolish investment short of anything less than a long term (5 year) sponsorship commitment.

    Case in point as far as different rules go - just a few years ago, IHRA had their own Top Fuel rules...25% over and some other changes. How well did that do? Due to the lack of NHRA teams crossing over, it was scrapped, and now the rules basically mirror NHRA.

    I think the class needs some sort of shot in the arm to give it a future.

    Change isn't mandatory, but neither is survival...
     
    #3
  4. T.Smith

    T.Smith Top Dragster

    Joined:
    May 22, 2003
    Messages:
    167
    Likes Received:
    0
    Nobody cares...so give up the roots blowers.

    Wanna run a roots? Go race Pro Mod or T/D.
     
    #4
  5. john348

    john348 Top Alcohol

    Joined:
    May 29, 2003
    Messages:
    1,348
    Likes Received:
    5
    How about this
    Ban the screw and only let the roots run in both IHRA and NHRA
    why let only one manufacture make a product
     
    #5
  6. Will Hanna

    Will Hanna We put the 'inside' in Top Alcohol
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    May 6, 2003
    Messages:
    6,706
    Likes Received:
    132
    realistic...

    let's be realistic here. screws in the nhra isn't the problem.

    ok, if screw blowers isn't the answer, what is?

    nostalgia bodies? altered bodies.

    i don't think staying the same buys the ihra afc class a future.

    maybe ethanol signs a 5 yr deal and yall are good.

    maybe they don't get a sponsor and this is a moot point.

    in that case you'll be buying a screw or a 63 split window vette....or a boat..
     
    #6
  7. Mark Billington

    Joined:
    Jun 21, 2003
    Messages:
    327
    Likes Received:
    4
    Being a guy on a budget who has run both IHRA and NHRA, roots and screw....I would think that if IHRA accepted the screw blowers, eventually car counts will go up for both IHRA and NHRA and the competiton will improve in both organizations. I agree with Will...the differentiation idea won't work. I've been very impressed with the performance of the roots cars in IHRA, but they are not spending less money than NHRA racers...maybe more. I think you'll get more car cross over and better competition in both organizations this way. This may be a mute point, if IHRA cans AFC then the strong cars will be coming over to NHRA and buying a screw...no if's or butt about that.
     
    #7
  8. bruce mullins

    bruce mullins Top Dragster

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2003
    Messages:
    1,002
    Likes Received:
    5
    a screw is not the answer or problem, the problem is the class went stale a few years ago. 5 or 6 years ago at the presidents cup 10 of the 16 cars were faster than a 5.90. so what changed since then. nothing! dale brand set the record at that race at a 5.72 four years later a 5.68 is the record. and now like mark said only 4 cars went to all the events. the idea of letting screw blower cars in would add new faces back in. you probably still wouldn't get that many more to run ALL the races, but you might get more cars at all the races with increased performances.
     
    #8
  9. Thurston

    Thurston New

    Joined:
    Oct 25, 2004
    Messages:
    183
    Likes Received:
    0
    Never say Never

    You have to compare apples to apples, and not Nitro to Alcohol. Nitro cars wherever they run stand on their own merit for what they are. Add in the cost of running a Top Fuel car and now the field of available cars becomes much smaller. More than enough reason to make the rules the same, and yes IHRA fans really like when a regular NHRA car shows up at an IHRA race. Why?? Has something to do with the differentiation thing we don’t agree on. Running a roots makes us different, I, we, fans, spectators, and I have to believe IHRA likes being unique, and knows how to market that to their advantage. Ask yourself why NHRA adopted Pro-Mod, because they are very popular with the spectators, good move NHRA see something successful, put in our show. Now ask why they went to a different set of rule this year, because they want their Pro-Mods to be than faster than the IHRA guys. NHRA has always promoted the fact that every class they run is faster than any other sanction body with a similar class. Why, because they want to stand out, they want to be different, they want to do more than just having IHRA Pro-Mods running at their tracks.

    Agreed the class is not out of the woods, but it's getting healthier each season. Aaron went to 8 car fields because we weren’t filling the 16 car fields. Fair enough, last year every race had full fields with an average car count of 12 and that’s after losing people like Jim Sickles, Scott Weney, Jimmy Rector, Billy Gibson, and so on. My point, in the last 3 years there’s been a lot of new blood in the class and some real strong regulars.

    I have great respect for the people that run alcohol in NHRA, they work very hard in a ultra completive class, it’s to bad they don’t get much respect in return from the folks in Glendora.

    I do agree that screws in NHRA is not the problem, change for change sake is not the answer either. The class needs a sponsor, but switching to screws just because NHRA runs them is not the answer. Even if they go back to a 16 car field I don’t see where that would make a big difference to a potential sponsor. The reason Lucus sponsors the class in NHRA is because Morgan raced TAD, now that he’s in a T/F even better. Not to mention a lot of alcohol car are his customers. A potential sponsor needs to see the class for what it is, recognize the advantages it brings (and there are many) and then capitalize on the those assets. I think Lucus oil is missing the boat by not involving himself more in IHRA, he’s missing a whole segment of drag racing customers, by not having a strong presents in IHRA. I have to believe Ethanol will see the advantages, kind of like having Mark Thomas only multiplying him by about 10 or 20.

    Will. It’s obvious you care about the class and it’s survival. Thanks for bring the subject to the table. Sure would like to hear what other people who care about this are thinking.

    Jim Thurston
     
    #9
  10. bruce mullins

    bruce mullins Top Dragster

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2003
    Messages:
    1,002
    Likes Received:
    5
    i admire you and the racers for sticking to their guns thurston, but here is my thought. the problem with ihra is they don't recognize the fact that most of the alcohol funny car teams are blue collar workers with familys and crew members are all doing this out of fun and devotion. because of this most of the teams can't make the full tour because ihra has spread there races from coat to coast, and even into canada 3 times a year. it is just imposible to run the tour unless you are independently wealthy or heavily sponsored. now you have to look at the areas that ihra is trying to get into. the west coast and down to texas has been nhra territory for too long , populated with screw cars. now ihra tries to go into these areas and the only oddball class they have is a/fc. all of your super classes to the fuel classes can crossover with ease. now ihra states because of small car counts they half to cut the fields and possibly do away with the class. you can't expect a nhra team to change their combo and purchase a roots blower for 1 race a year. (now i know this sounds like a broken record but) if ihra would have allowed screwblowers years ago nhra racers would have gladly crossed over into several ihra races and the fields would have never suffered at the new venues. i am not trying too start any arguments with anybody . hell i wish nhra had of outlawed the screws long ago, but these are the rules that we race with and these are the only classes with different rules. happy holidays!
     
    #10
  11. DQUES

    DQUES Member

    Joined:
    May 20, 2004
    Messages:
    650
    Likes Received:
    6
    I have often wondered about letting the screws into ihra . The purse is pretty good and just might tempt a few of the guys over to try it out . The new psi roots is almost as much as the screw and the screw can be run a lot longer before it needs serviced when a roots needs re-stripped quite often to keep the boost up at max . I don't know for sure but have heard you can run the screw all year without stripping it . As mentioned earlier , the class has become a little stale . If ihra was not slowing down the blown pro mods it would not be long before they would be posting times fast enough to qualify in some of the past fields , and this would not look to good for the af/c class . If Ethanol does pick up the tab , how much is the fuel going to cost per gallon ? , any guesses .
     
    #11
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2006
  12. bruce mullins

    bruce mullins Top Dragster

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2003
    Messages:
    1,002
    Likes Received:
    5
    the strips in a psi don't get re-done except when you send it back for re-cert every 3 years. imagine that, bolt it to the manifold and leave it alone for 3 whole years. :eek:
     
    #12
  13. eli

    eli Banned

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2005
    Messages:
    1,657
    Likes Received:
    1
    How about IHRA bans the roots and the screw and mandates injected nitro, they would be the only ones to have that set up, and i'll bet within two years or less they will be running high 5.30's 270. And from what i understand they will be cheaper to run. ;) :D
     
    #13
    Last edited: Dec 7, 2006
  14. michael hall

    michael hall New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 10, 2006
    Messages:
    280
    Likes Received:
    0
    get blown

    Why not go with nostalgia bodies, altered bodies, and injected nitro? The fans want to see something new. Who wouldn't want to see a blown altered run next to an injected nitro f/c? Or an old vette on nitro up against a newer blown Mustang? C'mon, lets give the people who spend their money to get in to the tracks a show. Mandatory 1/2 track burnouts, ACTUALLY interacting with the crowd getting them pumped up, having fun again. It stopped being fun and has just become a business. Just watch the interviews with some of the pro AND sportsmen guys and girls. The all are so serious and don;t seem to be having fun...that's why we sold our car years ago and now just play with our blown altered. Remember back in the 70's and 80's, before all the mandatory blowers, clutches, high paid crew chiefs? People ACTUALLY drove the car, tuned it, drove the truck/trailer to the track, worked on it all week. You didn;t just buy a tune up, you blew your stuff up to learn or just didn't make it past first round. I know about progress, but damn, when did it stop being fun?
     
    #14
  15. eli

    eli Banned

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2005
    Messages:
    1,657
    Likes Received:
    1

    It stopped being fun when the sportsman ranks got to be like the pro ranks, BIG MONEY SPONCERS, I rember running aginst you dad, we had the same setup (Donavan) only one, if we had spare sparkplus we were doing good, i had two extra pistons and two extra rods, after racing for 7 years I still had them pistons and rods, and gave them to the guy that bought the car, I also rember Joe Amato showing up with 3 spare motors, thats when I took the hint and got out, my brothers still are out there, frank shuster drives for vic and ant. tunes ickey ferro, I rember the battal cry was ARE WE HAVING FUN YET???? :rolleyes: :D
     
    #15
  16. Thurston

    Thurston New

    Joined:
    Oct 25, 2004
    Messages:
    183
    Likes Received:
    0
    Michael what you suggest is already happening. There are many organizations today promoting that type of racing. Case in point is the Bars Leak cars. Don’t know if you seen them, but the put on just the kind of show your talking about, big long burn outs, nostalgia bodies, super charged and nitrous. I’ve them twice and from what I can tell the spectators seem to like them. But if you think IHRA is going to change a class or create a new one just so racers can have fun, not have to work hard at it, and get paid to do so, your sadly mistaken. This is a business, and believe or not business can be fun and enjoyable. Something that has always gotten races of any type in trouble is thinking of this as something other than a business. There are sportsmen classes for those who, want to race, have fun and do it on a level that they themselves can support. Once you cross that line to a professional class everything changes, and that is what a lot of Alcohol racers struggle with; am I a sportsman or am I a professional?? I believe that’s what got IHRA’s AFC in trouble a few year back, many wanted to be act like, be treated like, get paid like a professional without putting in the dollars and the effort that it take to be a professional. As much as I hate to say it since they cut back to an 8-car field, the level of professionalism, the quality of the car and teams has improved. Quantity does not necessarily equal quality. Let’s go back to Bars Leak, Clay or whoever has done a great job of putting the nostalgia group together and promoting them. They have found a niche in the market and made the most of it, and that my friend, even if it wasn’t indented was a good business decision. But Bars Leak undoubtabally understands that racing is a business just look at the other car the fly and represent the Bars Leak Company, Bill Reichert, George Etterman, just to name 2. Do you really think Bars Leak sponsors them because Bill and George want to have some fun on the weekends?

    I’m a little of subject, so to get back to the real issue. What will keep IHRA’s AFC alive? I would like to think the racers have lived up to the commitment that was placed on them by IHRA when the cut back to the 8 car fields. We were told three things needed to happen. 1) There had to be full fields for every race, that has happen. 2) The quality of the cars needs to improve, that most certainly has happen. 3) The racers and teams need to be more professional, I feel that has happen also. Now it time for IHRA to step up to the plate, and live up to their side of the bargain, support the class and bring in a class sponsor, even if IHRA has to subsidize the class for another year or two, the racers certainly have invested in the future of the class.

    To hear or read a comment like yours about scares me, that type of approach will kill the class quicker than anything. Believe me IHRA views racing as a business, and the decision to keep or kill the class will be a business decision. Aaron or Scooter you got what you asked for, now can you step up and make it happen, the racers did.

    Racing is still fun, just that the price of the toys, ( just like everything else) has gone up!

    Jim Thurston
     
    #16
  17. Will Hanna

    Will Hanna We put the 'inside' in Top Alcohol
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    May 6, 2003
    Messages:
    6,706
    Likes Received:
    132
    few points

    few points-

    A/F FC - First problem with that being a 'solution' is who is going to invest in building one of these with a very questionable future for the category? Second is how you can make one of these run with a roots fc? Third is having a new, experimental class isn't what the class needs. Anyone who still clings to the fact that A/F anything is significantly cheaper than blown alcohol, I got some ocean front property in az that i'll make you a hell of a deal on site unseen.

    Nostalgia - I believe IHRA has been there and done that, a few 57 bodies were running a few years back. There are quite a few more nostalgia options today, but ok, lets say you give nostalgia bodies a weight break. well, most nostalgia bodies are fiberglass, so how are you going to take advantage of any said weight break? This might be a perk, entertain a few, but will have minimal impact on increasing participation or making the class more a fan draw for the sanctioning body and tracks.

    I don't buy into the fact that there are a significant number of drag racing fans that label themselves "i only go to ihra races" when both sanctioning bodies are within their region. if that was true, look for norwalk stands to be empty this year. rather, i think fans go to races based on distance from the house. i think fans preference goes deeper than sanctioning bodies or rules, i think when you get to the heart of their preference it probably boils down to either door cars, fuel cars, street legal or imports. cross over interest into other of these 'root' segments of our sport varies on the individual. i think the number of fans who follow or prefer 'ihra rules' or 'nhra rules' is minimal. of the fans that are 'ihra' fans, i would be willing to bet a large percent go to ihra events as an alternative to nhra after a bad experience.

    i hate to say it because i have a lot of friends racing ihra, but performances have gotten stale. that doesn't send a good message to the powers that be. the cars have been running the same numbers for years. newb and randy anderson ran in the .60's with roots years ago. granted i know for a long time the ihra tracks wasn't on the level with nhra which contributed, but the last few years there have been some quality tracks.

    are the racers just not smart enough? i don't think thats it, i just don't think there are enough cars pushing each other. there's only been one or two cars each year capable of .60's. when you increase the number of top running cars, they start pushing each other. numbers go down. honestly, how quick do you think manzo or newb would have ran by now had they been running roots full time since the early .90's?

    i think the class needs some new life in it. i think clinging to what you have and just hoping ihra will graciously allow you to run is a gameplan to not have a place to race.

    let's get proactive, get some dialogue, and see if we can get ihra to log in and bite.
     
    #17
  18. bobbyblue359

    bobbyblue359 New Member

    Joined:
    Nov 3, 2006
    Messages:
    154
    Likes Received:
    0
    Who WATCHES the 8.90 classes in either venue?------nobody. I would like to see parity between the sanctioning bodies, so alky burners could run both venues. Nothing like staying close to home and going racing. That makes car counts better. Both bodies need to make it exciting again-----we need some formats that gets the crowd excited. I had a track owner offer me an extra $100 to do a burnout and change lanes in the process. If they're that desperate, we have to do something. Small blocks in prostock truck didn't do it. What do you guys think will get the crowd back into it? Lottery for the fans if a particular car wins? ( I don't think that's legal in most states).
    Personally I'd like to see 10-25% nitro for the smell, the flames and the crowd appeal. That's why NHRA kept A-fuel. Small motors, light cars, nitro, and no blowers? C'mon Thurston, help me out here.
     
    #18
  19. Thurston

    Thurston New

    Joined:
    Oct 25, 2004
    Messages:
    183
    Likes Received:
    0
    Bob

    Cost aside, I believe injected nitro would realy wake up the class, but I don't believe IHRA would allow that to happen. I remember watching (I think it was) Scott Wies run his at a IHRA race, easliy out pacing the entire field. IHRA tried it once and it didn't last long for whatever reason. Given all the parity problems it would be the same nightmare NHRA has with the dragsters, and just knowing how dangerous it is just to start one of these, I just don't see it happening.
     
    #19
  20. michael hall

    michael hall New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 10, 2006
    Messages:
    280
    Likes Received:
    0
    like I said, it has become just a business, not a sport. I remember as a kid pulling into the track and our whole circuit( Fuel Funny Car Promotions), would all hang out, talk, laugh, eat and help each other with their cars if help was needed. There are still a few teams that interact, share food, drink, crew, and just enjoy the friendship and racing together. But for the majority, that is gone and it has become just a business, 9-5 go to work kinda job where nobody smiles, laughs, and just has fun. A guy wins a race, loads his car and is gone before the first round loser is gone from the track. No celebration, no laughter or hanging with fellow racers. It's sad. And i'm 35, grew up at the races with a funny car in my garage, and that was my life,so I do know a little about the subject.
     
    #20

Share This Page